featured image

18 November 2026

North Sydney Council has launched a formal challenge to a proposed eight-storey retirement apartment development in Mosman, warning that residents across the council boundary in Cremorne will bear the consequences of planning decisions over which they have little influence.

Retirement living operator Aveo has lodged a $72.1 million development application to demolish five houses at 27–35 Macpherson Street and replace them with a 29.8-metre building containing 45 independent living apartments and 61 basement parking spaces.

Although the site falls within Mosman Council’s boundaries, it directly faces low-rise homes in Cremorne and the Montague Road Heritage Conservation Area, raising concerns about overshadowing, privacy, traffic and the impact of high-rise development on the neighbourhood.

North Sydney Council voted unanimously on November 9 to oppose aspects of Mosman’s broader planning proposals and prepare a submission on the Aveo application.

The intervention follows growing frustration among residents on both sides of Macpherson Street, who argue that the council boundary has created a planning blind spot.

COUNCIL WARNS OF POOR PLANNING TRANSITION

North Sydney Council first raised concerns about development along the shared boundary in May, when Mosman exhibited its draft masterplan.

Its submission warned that buildings of eight storeys on the Mosman side of Macpherson Street would sit abruptly opposite two-storey housing in Cremorne, without the gradual transition envisaged in the masterplan’s own design principles.

“It would be helpful, as an urban design exercise, to consider the built environment more holistically without the constraints of a hard local government boundary artificially limiting consideration of a wider understanding of the urban fabric,” North Sydney Council said.

Despite those concerns, Mosman subsequently endorsed a planning proposal allowing substantially greater development across several sites near the boundary.

North Sydney Council’s November meeting was told that Mosman’s subsequent reports had not specifically addressed its earlier objections and that no further consultation had occurred between the councils since May.

Councillors have now resolved to write to Mosman seeking the removal of proposed high-rise gateway sites at the intersection of Military Road and Macpherson Street.

They also agreed to make submissions opposing aspects of both the masterplan and the Aveo development.

EIGHT STOREYS COULD BE FIRST STEP TOWARDS TWELVE

The controversy extends beyond the immediate eight-storey proposal.

Mosman’s planning proposal identifies the wider Manors retirement village as a key development site where buildings of up to 12 storeys could eventually be permitted.

The proposed uplift would allow buildings reaching 43 metres, subject to the delivery of public benefits including 2,000 square metres of publicly accessible open space and a pedestrian link through the site.

Residents argue that Aveo is using this prospective future development potential to support its current application, despite the wider planning changes not yet being finalised.

They also point out that the standalone application does not deliver the public open space and other benefits envisaged under the broader proposal.

The existing local planning height limit is 8.5 metres, while residents say the proposed 29.8-metre building also exceeds the height limits available under the NSW Government’s low and mid-rise housing provisions.

RESIDENTS RAISE PRIVACY AND SAFETY CONCERNS

A flyer circulating among Mosman and Cremorne residents raises concerns about the development’s height, setbacks, loss of sunlight, tree removal and traffic impacts.

Residents claim the proposed building would stand just 2.3 metres from the Macpherson Street boundary, compared with a six-metre setback benchmark, with upper-level windows overlooking neighbouring properties.

They are also concerned about the removal of 35 trees, including a mature jacaranda, and the effects of construction traffic on children walking to nearby Middle Harbour Public School.

The proposed basement would accommodate 61 vehicles, with access via Macpherson Street.

The flyer also questions the implications for existing residents of The Manors retirement village, which Aveo manages, particularly the proximity of the proposed excavation and new apartments to neighbouring residences.

These concerns remain allegations made by residents and will need to be assessed through the development application process.

North Sydney Council’s intervention follows a community meeting on November 6 attended by residents from both council areas and the North Sydney Mayor.

The council has specifically identified the interests of residents in Macpherson Street, Prospect Avenue, Richmond Avenue, Montague Road and surrounding streets as reasons for its involvement.

The application remains under assessment by Mosman Council.